GENERAL SURGERY
One in three Americans is medically obese. One in four live somewhere without ready access to ICU-level surgical care in an emergency. These are the gaps the Department of Surgery's general surgery teams are working to close, in weight management, rural trauma access, and robotic trauma surgery. Listen to the full conversations, browse extras beyond the book, and read complete transcripts, streaming wherever you get your podcasts.
Beyond the Scale
A Comprehensive Approach to Weight Management
One in three Americans is medically obese, and weight stigma, in both society and medicine, has long kept many from ever seeking treatment. Dr. Eric Volckmann says that’s beginning to shift, as new medications make it easier to see obesity as a treatable condition rather than a personal failing, though up to 75% of people on those same drugs stop taking them within two years.
Join us to learn how this team is building a program that treats obesity as lifelong, not a quick fix.
TRANSCRIPTS, PHOTOS & MORE
This transcript was created from an audio recording of Voices of Surgery. Spoken conversation doesn't always translate perfectly to the page, so small edits have been made here for readability and clarity. If you're able to listen, we'd encourage it: the tone, the pauses, the moments of laughter, all come through best in the original audio. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts to catch every episode.
The opinions expressed by our hosts and guests are their own and don't necessarily reflect the official views of the University of Utah or the Department of Surgery.
Introduction
Eric Volckmann: We see a lot of weight stigma and weight bias, both in society and in medicine.
Interviewer: Welcome to Voices of Surgery. I'm Niki Tonks, and I'm Keslie Ta'afua. One podcast. Many voices shaping the future of surgery. I'm Niki, and today I have with me Dr. Eric Volckmann, a director of bariatric surgery.
Eric Volckmann: Hi. Thanks for having me. My name is Eric Volckmann. I'm the director of bariatric surgery at the University of Utah. I'm also the section chief of gastroesophageal and bariatric surgery, and the co-director of the Comprehensive Weight Management Clinic.
Interviewer: Well, we're excited to have you here today. Today we're going to talk about weight management and how it's really more than just weight loss. One of the first questions that I want to ask around this whole subject is, tell me something that should not be true, but unfortunately is.
Something That Should Not Be True
Eric Volckmann: I think one thing that we see a lot and that we wish wasn't true, but is, is that we see a lot of weight stigma and weight bias, both in society and in medicine.
How Weight Stigma Affects People
Interviewer: Yeah, that's really unfortunate. And tell me more about how that impacts folks.
Eric Volckmann: It impacts folks tremendously. I mean, there's first the health effects. It affects patients' health in terms of things like diabetes, cancer risk, heart disease, pulmonary function, joint pain, arthritis. It affects just about every body system. But when it comes to weight stigma and discrimination, it can affect how people socialize in groups, it can affect promotion and advancements. It can affect even kind of how they're treated in the health care setting and the care that they receive. It's sometimes looked at different than other medical problems, where this is a, you know, potentially a fault of the patient rather than a medical problem, or that they've been fighting for a long time and trying to make themselves healthier.
Interviewer: I think it's really hard to understand that from those perspectives, unless you're living it and understanding it and even researching it and seeing how those effects are.
More Than a Lifestyle Issue
Interviewer: Tell me how obesity is more than just a lifestyle issue.
Eric Volckmann: It's really multifactorial. Our lives have become much more sedentary. So in the course of our day, we're getting a lot less steps. We're burning a lot less calories. The foods that we eat are highly processed with a lot more calories in them. Portion sizes are really large, so we've got more calories coming in. We're burning less calories and our lives are getting busier and busier. For a lot of people, it's really difficult to make the time that they need to exercise or plan their meals. And then we kind of spiral and things get out of control with regard to weight. If we look at obesity in this country, about 1 in 3 individuals is considered obese by body mass index. And that's, you know, body mass index 30 or higher. In some states in this country it's over 40%. So it gets higher every year. At least a third of our population is considered medically obese. So it is a big public health issue that needs to be addressed.
Life After Weight Loss Surgery
Interviewer: Can you talk to me a little bit about how somebody that's struggling with this is impacted?
Eric Volckmann: Yeah. You know, one of the biggest dramatic things we see after weight loss surgery is improvement in patients' quality of life. They can participate in activities again with their families that they couldn't perform. Sometimes they say, I can, you know, ride an amusement park ride that I couldn't fit on and walk around, say, Disneyland all day. Patients' baseline activity goes up. The overwhelming response I hear from patients after surgery is that [unclear] decision I ever made, would do it again. The joint pain gets better. Patients sleep better. They're taking less pills.
GLP-1 Medications: A Tool in the Toolbox
Interviewer: So there's something that's really taking over the industry, which is the GLP-1s. Can you talk to me a little bit about how the emergence of GLP-1 medications has changed the way patients are cared for, and is that really the only magic bullet?
Eric Volckmann: I hate to call it a magic bullet, but it is a tool in our toolbox and it has added to our tools in our toolbox. So the underpinnings of weight loss are, as I mentioned before, really diet and activity. But for a lot of people, you know, it gets to a point where that's not enough and we need to add something else. And so there are options. And it's not one size fits all. For some patients, medications may be a better initial option. For some patients who are carrying more weight, they may need something more effective at those higher body mass index, like surgery. So it really is a spectrum of what we're able to offer patients. And I think one thing that's been great about the medications is that they've offered a weight loss intervention to more people. And when we talk about weight loss stigma, it's really made it more acceptable, I think, for society in general to accept that obesity is a medical problem that can be treated, and now we have an intervention for it. So I think what it has done, it has broadened the number of patients that we're able to reach out to. Not everyone responds to the medications. Some patients don't lose the weight that they want with them. Some patients can have gastrointestinal side effects with them. So, you know, there's a market for surgery and the medication. So we kind of look at it as a spectrum of what we're able to offer. One thing to consider when you're considering any weight loss intervention is you should consider a lifelong intervention. Obviously, when we're talking surgery, it's very hard and in some cases not possible at all to reverse a surgery. When it comes to the medications, generally when they're stopped, patients will experience weight regain. It's important for patients to consider that as they're going on to the medications, especially when we look at the medications out about two years, they can have a 75% discontinuation rate.
Interviewer: Wow.
Eric Volckmann: So, and that can be for a number of different reasons. It can be due to cost, side effects, those kinds of things. At the Comprehensive Weight Management Clinic, we have both medical and surgical providers. 1 in 3 Utahns have obesity. We're clearly not treating 1 in 3. So there's a lot of people out there who need an intervention. I often tell patients that we all know that smoking is really bad for us and affects our health negatively in many, many ways. Obesity is right there up with it. If you look at it, it increases your cancer risk and it increases all kinds of medical problems. And so taking care of that is really important for patients.
A Multidisciplinary Approach
Interviewer: Can you tell me a little bit how the multidisciplinary specialties are working together in your system, and how that might be unique to the University of Utah?
Eric Volckmann: Within our program, we have dietitians who specialize in weight management, we have exercise physiologists. We have a very close working relationship with sleep medicine, hepatology. We do FibroScans in our clinic. We have, you know, almost an equal number of medical and surgical providers who work out of our clinic. We have our own dedicated psychologists who work with our program. So we have a lot of specialists and we all work together as a team. We're all based out of the same clinic, so that we're able to see patients and provide them the care that they need. So it really works well together.
Interviewer: That's amazing. So when someone comes in, you're not just looking at them from a BMI index, you're really looking at them as a whole person, right? From their psychological to their physiological. And what type of intervention works the best.
Eric Volckmann: Absolutely. You know, I think you can't treat weight as a number and in a vacuum. When you come into the surgical side of our program for our surgical consultation, you're coming in with a full set of nutritional labs. You're getting an endoscopy, a psychological evaluation. You're getting educated by the dietitians. All this is happening before surgery. And then, you know, we're seeing patients at two weeks, six weeks, three months, six months, yearly for life and checking labs and making sure patients are staying healthy.
Medication Isn't Just a Prescription
Eric Volckmann: Now, when we're talking about medications, those things also need to be happening, right? So it's more than just prescribing a medication. Patients need to be educated on how much protein they need. We should be checking nutritional labs, making sure patients aren't protein deficient, which can cause muscle wasting, hair loss. A lot of patients walk in the door and they've got vitamin D deficiency or other nutritional deficiencies that really need to be screened for. Are people getting screened for sleep apnea? I would say for patients who are coming for surgical evaluation, 80 plus percent of patients have sleep apnea, which can affect diabetes, hypertension, your daytime fatigue, weight loss. That really should be being checked in patients who are being placed on medications. Also when patients are losing weight rapidly, and one of the things that the GLP-1s do is they reduce what patients are eating, just like surgery, if you're not able to get everything that you need from your diet, then you need to be getting it from a supplement. So those patients should be taking vitamins, and we should be checking for vitamin and nutritional deficiencies. So these are the considerations that we really need to be paying attention to. If we're not careful as we prescribe these medications in large numbers, those can become issues. Same thing with gallstone formation. When you lose weight rapidly, you can form gallstones. And so we're seeing an uptick in number of patients needing their gallbladder removed. These are all things that really need to be paid attention to. And that's one benefit of going to a provider who is American Board of Obesity Medicine certified, as all of our medical providers are, that they know about these things. You know, oh, hey, you're losing a lot of weight. We need to place you on ursodiol so you don't form gallstones. We should be checking to make sure you don't have nutritional deficiencies before we place you on these medications and then try others.
Passing Patients Between Medical and Surgical Care
Eric Volckmann: In our own program we pass patients back and forth all the time. So there might be a patient on the medical side who's not seeing the results they want, and they pass them over to surgery. And we might have someone who's not a good surgical candidate or maybe hasn't achieved the goals they want with surgery, and we send them over to the medical side. So that's where having a comprehensive team can come into play. There's also going to be emotional eating, eating for reasons other than hunger, stress, boredom, anxiety, depression. And that's where having a good staff of psychologists and providers who recognize that that requires a different intervention, that a medication maybe won't help with, or a surgery for that matter. So having experts in those areas ends up being really important.
Advice for Other Programs
Interviewer: If we have other surgeons or physicians or weight centers across the nation or even locally listening to this, what's one thing that you would hope that they would take away, that maybe they could help to incorporate or bring into their programs to make them more whole?
Eric Volckmann: I would say treat every patient as an individual. There's not one right intervention for everybody. These are all tools in the toolbox, as I mentioned earlier. And so what is the best intervention for a patient? So being knowledgeable about what the benefits are of each intervention. Each intervention, whether it's a medicine or a surgery, will have some risks associated with it. It's going to have benefits associated with it. They'll have different amounts of weight loss. And so what are the patient's goals?
How Medicine's View of Obesity Is Changing
Interviewer: How has this changed the way medicine thinks about obesity?
Eric Volckmann: I think people are more willing to talk openly about the fact that they're on a medication for weight loss or that they're having a weight loss intervention. And I think as we see more of it, people realize that these things are safe and acceptable. I will frequently tell patients that in the modern era, when you have bariatric surgery, the risk of complications and death is actually less than it is having your gallbladder removed or even having your appendix removed. So they're very safe in the modern era.
What Still Needs to Change?
Interviewer: So what still needs to change? What do you hope for the future?
Eric Volckmann: That one day, you know, we will no longer see weight bias and obesity stigma. And that will be put on par with any other medical problem, whether it's, you know, heart disease, liver disease, hypertension. And it's just one other thing that we treat on a daily basis. And it becomes part of our, you know, baseline medical school education. I think when you see it every day and you hear the stories from patients about, you know, some of the hardships that they faced, and then you see how happy they are at one year and beyond, it really is the best part of my job. You see lots of smiles, lots of hugs, a lot of happy patients. And that really makes you passionate about what you do.
Closing Thoughts
Interviewer: Well, thank you for joining me today, Dr. Volckmann. I really appreciate your time, and I really hope that the discussion that we've had today can inspire not only our folks listening, but beyond.
Eric Volckmann: Thanks for having me.
Voices of Surgery Sign-Off
Interviewer: Thank you for joining us for Voices of Surgery. I'm Niki Tonks, your host and producer, and I'm Keslie Ta'afua, your co-producer. Every voice has a story, and we hope you'll join us next time to hear another.
Scope Podcast with Dr. Volckmann: When Does Acid Reflux Require Surgery, Not Just Medication?
Closing the Rural Transfer Gap
A System to Get Rural Patients the Right Care, Fast
One in four Americans live somewhere with little to no access to advanced, ICU-level surgical care in an emergency, and even in a state with world-class trauma centers, survival can still come down to zip code.
Dr. Marta McCrum’s research maps how hospitals are, and aren’t, connected, showing that rural hospitals fare best not as centers to bypass, but as partners in a coordinated network. Find out how she’s working to make sure zip code stops deciding who survives.
TRANSCRIPTS, PHOTOS & MORE
This transcript was created from an audio recording of Voices of Surgery. Spoken conversation doesn't always translate perfectly to the page, so small edits have been made here for readability and clarity. If you're able to listen, we'd encourage it: the tone, the pauses, the moments of laughter, all come through best in the original audio. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts to catch every episode.
The opinions expressed by our hosts and guests are their own and don't necessarily reflect the official views of the University of Utah or the Department of Surgery.
Introduction
Marta McCrum: In a state like Utah where we have world class surgical trauma and critical care expertise, a patient's outcome can still depend heavily on where they live, where they're injured, and which hospital they reach first.
Interviewer: Welcome to Voices of Surgery. I'm Niki Tonks, and I'm Keslie Ta'afua. One podcast. Many voices shaping the future of surgery. I'm Niki, and today I'm joined by Dr. Marta McCrum, an acute care surgeon and health services researcher whose work is helping improve access to surgical care for patients living in rural communities across Utah and the Mountain West. Thank you for joining me.
Marta McCrum: Thanks so much for having me.
Interviewer: So tell me a little bit about what you do.
Marta McCrum: I'm a trauma and acute care surgeon, which means clinically, I take care of patients who are injured or who have nontraumatic surgical emergencies and need, you know, urgent or emergent surgical evaluation and care. I also work as an intensive care doctor in our surgical ICU. From a research perspective, I study how patients access care for emergency surgical conditions and what we can do to improve their outcomes and help them recover.
Something That Should Not Be True
Interviewer: Tell me something that should not be true, but is.
Marta McCrum: In a state like Utah where we have world class surgical trauma and critical care expertise, a patient's outcome can still depend heavily on where they live, where they're injured, and which hospital they reach first.
Why Where You Live Matters
Interviewer: That's really unfortunate. A lot of times, those of us who live right here just take it for granted, right? That we have something happen in the middle of the night. We jump up and we go to the nearest ER. Why is that different for somebody who doesn't live her?
Marta McCrum: For patients who live in rural communities or in communities that don't have rapid access to surgical care, they're—delays in reaching definitive care. Delays can result in death or major complications or really difficult recoveries. Time really matters in these situations. And so there's a big difference between patients and people who live in urban communities where there are robust health services available and those that don't.
Emergency Conditions That Can't Wait
Interviewer: What are some of these conditions that people might have emergently or urgently that, you know, maybe again, we take for granted, like maybe my appendix, you know, hurt. I'm in the middle of the night. I don't know what it is. So I can just get up and go to the ER.
Marta McCrum: Yeah. So, I mean, I do treat patients with traumatic injuries, and that's pretty easy for most people to understand if you get hurt or have an accident. But some of these other conditions. You're right. Appendicitis is a really common one. Gallbladder conditions are another one that we see people present with emergencies. We also treat a lot of bowel obstructions, bowel perforations of various types and really severe soft tissue infections that can rapidly progress and kill people.
Interviewer: And you said timing is really important. Tell me about that.
Marta McCrum: So for many of these conditions we think about bleeding and sepsis. Those are two major emergencies. So in the case of bleeding, once again, that's pretty easy for most folks to understand, that you need to stop the bleeding rapidly. If infections are not treated rapidly. And when we think about surgical infections, those are ones that often require surgery or some sort of definitive intervention to control the infection. If that doesn't happen rapidly, people can get very sick and die.
Interviewer: And so the timing of maybe me here, living in the city, taking 15 minutes to get to a care center, whereas somebody maybe living eight hours away from a complex medical center, like that's a major difference between life and death.
Marta McCrum: Yeah, absolutely. Certainly in the region that we serve here at the University of Utah, which includes parts of five different states, we see huge differences in patients who are able to present early because they live down the street versus those who may live, for example, in northern Nevada and have to go to their local hospital and then transport is arranged, and then they have transport time added to that, all to get here and be treated.
The Complicated Transfer Process
Interviewer: Talk to me a little bit more about that transport time.
Marta McCrum: So, I think that transfer and transport process is really important. It's also incredibly complicated. There are some conditions like trauma, for example, where we've recognized the importance of time and over decades have developed a really robust trauma system where we're able to expedite those transfers. And that means not just having, you know, ambulance, EMS crews, air transport teams available, but also having transfer agreements where those transfers are rapidly expedited. For other conditions that haven't had those systems developed and those agreements developed. And for this, I'm using the comparison of these non-traumatic surgical emergencies, like a bowel obstruction, it can be much, much harder for that transfer process to occur rapidly. That means that emergency doctors in rural hospitals need to find an accepting hospital that has beds available. They have to call. They have to find someone who's able to take the transfer, that they need to ensure that the hospital has beds available in the right area, whether that's, you know, on the inpatient floors or whether that's an ICU. Then you have to arrange transport. Sometimes that can be difficult because of weather, and so then hospitals have to look for other options. So this is just one thing that we think about, as just a transfer can be incredibly complex when we don't have the systems to support it.
Interviewer: Right. So, it is not just a transfer. It really is every condition that you could have, plus the systems involved really complicating the issue even further. I can see how that would really impact the timing of the care that somebody needs. Is that something that your research is working on?
Marta McCrum: Yes. So, it's a large, complicated issue when we're thinking about rural patients accessing high level surgical care for emergencies. Part of what we're doing is looking at transfers and where patients go, the pathways that they use to access care. We're also working on understanding more about the timing and delays of transfers and how to make transfers more predictable, more efficient and more successful for the patients.
Studying Access: The Data Challenge
Interviewer: Are you looking at data as it's happening, or are you looking at past data? How are you discovering this?
Marta McCrum: For the most part, we're using retrospective data or past data, and our group has primarily used claims data. This is one of the really challenging parts of this work because the different data systems don't necessarily talk to or link with each other. So we do have national EMS data. We do have local electronic medical record data at local hospitals, at the University of Utah we have data on outpatient clinics so we can follow how they do afterwards. But none of these data systems talk to each other, and many of them won't link to each other.
Interviewer: Oh, that's frustrating.
Marta McCrum: So it's a very challenging problem to address in a really coordinated way. Most of what we're doing right now is using administrative claims data where we can link geographically the different admissions and transfers, look at where patients are treated, follow them across their transfers, and then assess their outcomes.
What the Research Has Found
Interviewer: So what have you uncovered to this point and what are you doing next? Like what is the next step?
Marta McCrum: So if we think about the work that we're doing on access to emergency surgical care, we started off using geospatial analysis to describe nationally patterns of access to care that include not just distance, but also hospital capacity and then population demand. So using more comprehensive metrics of what access really means for a given area, we started doing that kind of descriptive work and describing disparities in populations and communities that had lower access to care. We are then looking at different methods for quantifying the organization of transfers, how well defined transfer patterns are, how chaotic or disorganized they are, and how that influences or contributes to patient outcomes.
Interviewer: So with that, do you have any initial findings of what you're seeing so far that you're taking to that next step?
Marta McCrum: So going back to our early work, we found that 110 million residents in the United States have or live in an area that's considered low access to emergency surgical care, and that's just basic emergency surgical care. So that's a healthy person who needs their appendix out. 1 in 4 lives in a low access area for advanced emergency surgical care. So that includes hospitals that are able to care for the sickest patients, people who need ICU care. So that was surprising in itself. Now when we look at the regions and the organization of transfers within regions, we start to see a signal that if you live in a region where there's greater organization in the health care system, in between hospitals, there is a benefit in terms of mortality. Those patients tend to have better outcomes. So when we think about the different places that you can receive care, being in an organized system seems to do better for everybody.
Interviewer: What's next in this process for you?
What's Next: Making Hospitals Work Together
Marta McCrum: I think what's next for us is learning more about the organization of health systems for emergency surgical care on a national basis, and then translating that into actionable findings. And part of those interventions will be working on systems that help hospitals to work together. Right now hospitals are working fairly independently of each other. And I think we need to encourage and incentivize communities of hospitals to work together so that we can do things like expedite transfers and we can ensure reliable flow of information. We can triage patients so that patients who can stay closer to home in rural communities and in their local hospitals can do so without being transferred unnecessarily. But at the same time, we can expedite the transfer of the patients who really need to reach tertiary centers or academic centers like the University of Utah, where we have all the technology and services that you can imagine.
Hearing from Rural Communities
Interviewer: I know this is a big looking-forward question, but my next question is always like, do you have a sense of how to do this? Do you have an idea of what you think might be the answer to it?
Marta McCrum: Well, I think the first place that we need to start is hearing from patients and from family members and from clinicians and colleagues in rural communities, and have people start talking to each other. I think we all want the same thing, which is best outcomes for the population that we serve. And certainly in Utah, I think there is a real sense of mission across the state in how we think about and care for rural communities. I think what we need to do is hear more from patients, from clinicians, from administrators at different hospitals and have everyone talk to each other to start, so that we're not thinking about only within our own needs and our experience, but that we're hearing the experience from other people.
Interviewer: So you've started with the quantitative retrospective analysis, and you're thinking maybe like a future-based qualitative analysis, listening to people where they're at.
Marta McCrum: Yeah, we've started doing this with trauma patients because another component of my work has been working with rural trauma patients and trying to improve systems that support them in their recovery after they leave the hospital here. And we've been reaching out to rural patients, their caregivers and other clinicians involved in the care of these populations nationally. So not just within Utah, to understand more about their stories, barriers to recovery, the facilitators, the things that have helped them in recovery after leaving tertiary trauma centers after major injuries, to understand more about what needs to be done to address their own lived experiences and their stories.
Rural Communities Are Strong and Resilient
Interviewer: Yeah. And clearly there are some links, right, that are working well and things happen. Like you said, if the communities are working tightly together, it seems like those communities are doing better.
Marta McCrum: I think one thing that sometimes gets overlooked is the resilience and the strength of rural communities. And so I think it's really important to emphasize that the goal here is not to centralize all care and that everything needs to be dealt with at an academic center, but to identify when it's appropriate to be keeping patients in their home communities because we really need those rural hospitals. They play a key role in care of rural patients, but also in surgical emergencies. So we need to support those health care systems and those patients in their incredibly strong and resilient communities. But then we also need to be able to form better systems and better connections with hospitals that are able to provide that high level tertiary care when needed.
Bringing Care Back Home
Interviewer: Yeah, the right care at the right place at the right time. But oftentimes these folks need long term care. And it doesn't make sense for them to come to this massive medical institution here when they live eight hours away. So it's that transferring the care back so people can continue to receive that follow-up care.
Marta McCrum: Yeah. And I think that there's a lot of opportunities for us to figure out how to do that more effectively. And certainly telehealth has become more integrated in what we do. And we're able to provide patients with telehealth appointments. It's not appropriate for everything though. We found in our work understanding trauma that there are periods of time, and particularly the early post-acute care time, where there are certain things that require coming back for things like wound care and staples and sometimes X-rays and those sorts of things. So not everything can be accomplished by telehealth, particularly in surgical settings. We can also figure out how we can better communicate with their primary care doctor or surgeons in their local community to help avoid those frequent and very long and costly travel for post-op care.
Learners and Collaborators
Interviewer: We're an academic medical institution. Is this something that you have learners working with you on, the research or on the rural care, and how does that impact what you're doing?
Marta McCrum: Absolutely. Yeah. I have a long-standing collaboration with Dr. Ning Wan in the Department of Geography. And so we've had a number of graduate students, master's and PhD students, work on some of the geospatial work and network analysis work. We work with Dr. J.J. Horns in the Department of Surgery, who's our statistician, to do some of the quantitative work, and we've sometimes had students working with us on some of this, we've had medical students working with us as well. And certainly our medical students here at the University of Utah are very motivated and interested in rural care. We've had all range of learners involved in this.
Interviewer: That's exciting to have the collaborations. And I'm assuming those students really enjoy working on this kind of work too, because it makes them think outside the box.
Marta McCrum: They've expressed that it's interesting because it feels really meaningful. It's not just methods driven, but there's a very real and meaningful outcome that the work relates to. And we get to learn from each other, which I think is really wonderful. They'll teach me about some of the methodological approaches and how they think about the analysis and the different tools that can be used. And then when we're going through the results, I'm able to say as a clinician, well, this really rings true to me because this is how I think about it as a clinician or this is what I see. So we're able to learn from each other in a really multidisciplinary way, which has been a lot of fun.
What Do You Hope Will Be True Someday?
Interviewer: With all of this work that you're doing, understanding this is still a challenge and you're still working through it and there's still phases. What do you hope will be true someday because of the work you're doing today?
Marta McCrum: I hope someday that rural patients and family members will know that when they have a problem, particularly if it involves having to see a surgeon or if they're injured, that when they show up at their local hospital, or when they call an ambulance or EMS, that there's going to be a chain of care that's going to take care of them and offer them the best outcome possible. And they're not going to have to worry about the geography or where they live impacting their ultimate outcome. I also hope that our rural colleagues and clinicians feel supported and feel like they are part of a global team and not isolated. I think that's really important that we start to work more as a large team in health care and not necessarily as individual entities that are just, you know, connected through transports or through EMS, that we're all part of one team and one system. I mean, the patients that I work with, their problems are not something where they have time to Google three different doctors and get recommendations on who they should see. They need to trust that the system is going to work for them no matter what.
Closing Thoughts
Interviewer: Yeah, I think that's incredibly insightful and it's not for them to have the mental load. It's for us to do the work in advance and make sure that the work that we're doing is putting them in the best position. Well, thanks for joining me today. This has been really insightful. I'm excited to see what comes next. And thank you for doing the work that you're doing. We live in a really unique place, but I also think that it gives us the opportunity to care for and meet some really unique and amazing people who really appreciate the work you're doing.
Marta McCrum: Wonderful. Thanks so much. This was fun.
Voices of Surgery Sign-Off
Interviewer: Thank you for joining us for Voices of Surgery. I'm Niki Tonks, your host and producer, and I'm Keslie Ta'afua, your co-producer. Every voice has a story, and we hope you'll join us next time to hear another.
Trauma Meets Technology
Bringing Robotics and a New Mindset to Trauma Surgery
For years, acute care surgeons leaned on maximally invasive approaches because it felt safer. Dr. Alexander Colonna is one of a growing number bringing robotic surgery into trauma care, while Dr. Devi Krishnamurty, the program’s new residency director, works to train the next generation to adopt new tools safely at the same time. Find out how surgeons are teaching each other, and their trainees, to rethink what “safest” really means.
TRANSCRIPTS, PHOTOS & MORE
This transcript was created from an audio recording of Voices of Surgery. Spoken conversation doesn't always translate perfectly to the page, so small edits have been made here for readability and clarity. If you're able to listen, we'd encourage it: the tone, the pauses, the moments of laughter, all come through best in the original audio. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts to catch every episode.
The opinions expressed by our hosts and guests are their own and don't necessarily reflect the official views of the University of Utah or the Department of Surgery.
Introduction
Alexander Colonna: Well, I think in acute care surgery we tend to pick the most maximally invasive approaches because we're most comfortable with that. We think, at least anecdotally, that that's quicker, safer for the patient in an emergency situation. But some of the newer data that's coming out and some of our own experience tells us that perhaps we should focus more on minimally invasive techniques in acute care surgery, and certainly the arrival of a very competent surgical robotics platform has allowed us to perform a lot more of our emergency operations in a minimally invasive fashion.
Interviewer: Welcome to Voices of Surgery. I'm Niki Tonks, and I'm Keslie Ta'afua. One podcast. Many voices shaping the future of surgery. I'm Niki, and today I'm joined by Dr. Alexander Colonna, an acute care surgeon helping pioneer robotic surgery in acute care and trauma, and Dr. Devi Krishnamurty, program director for the General Surgery residency, whose work is helping prepare the next generation of surgeons for the future of surgical care. Thank you for joining me today. Tell me a little bit about yourselves.
Alexander Colonna: Yeah, I'm Alexander Colonna. I'm one of the long-standing acute care surgeons here at the University of Utah. And I'm also the program director for the surgical critical care and acute care surgery fellowships.
Devi Krishnamurty: My name is Devi Krishnamurty. I'm a colon and rectal surgeon and the new program director for the General Surgery residency at the University of Utah. Thank you for joining me today. I'm really excited to talk about this.
Interviewer: This is kind of a unique interview because we have two people who really have to work together, one in clinical care and in teaching, and then another who is really focusing on how we get this next generation of individuals up to speed in technology. So I'm going to start with a question, and that is: tell me something that shouldn't be true, but is.
Something That Should Not Be True
Alexander Colonna: Well, I think in acute care surgery we tend to pick the most maximally invasive approaches because we're most comfortable with that. We think, at least anecdotally, that that's quicker, safer for the patient in an emergency situation. But some of the newer data that's coming out and some of our own experience tells us that perhaps we should focus more on minimally invasive techniques in acute care surgery, and certainly the arrival of a very competent surgical robotics platform has allowed us to perform a lot more of our emergency operations in a minimally invasive fashion. So I hope in the future we won't be referred to as maximally invasive surgeons, and that we will use the appropriate tool for the appropriate patient.
Training on the Job and Learning New Technology
Devi Krishnamurty: From an educator's perspective, what has been true about surgery for generations is that we train on the job, which means when our trainees are learning how to operate, they are doing it on real patients. With the explosion of technology that we've had over the last 30 years, now it seems like there's more to learn, and quickly, in the same time frame. So simulation has become a lot more important. And as we introduce new technology like robotics, we are also learning how to train our residents to be safe while also being competent with the new technologies that are exploding in front of us.
Interviewer: And I can imagine, from you learning yourself how to be a minimally invasive, not maximally invasive, surgeon, learning and teaching at the same time, it's got to be complex.
Alexander Colonna: Well, yeah, it can be. You know, I started residency almost 20 years ago now, and I was trained in minimally invasive techniques, laparoscopy. And the robotic platform is really a fancy version of laparoscopic surgery. So while it is very exciting and technically very innovative, the principles of minimally invasive surgery are the same, and those have been developed since the 1980s. So we've actually been doing this kind of surgery for many, many years. The robotic platform allows us to have a little bit more control, a little bit better visualization, and allows us to take care of acutely ill patients a little bit better than traditional laparoscopy. So I think it's just a better tool than some of the tools we have had in the past for minimally invasive surgery. And learning it was just fun. I'm a big nerd. I love technology. I've been very into computers and tech since I was a little kid, so this is just another aspect of playing video games to me, sitting at the console and operating. So it's been very fun and easy for me to learn robotics. I think some people without my hobbies may find it a little bit more challenging. It sounds very cool, but fundamentally it is tried and true technology, because we've been doing minimally invasive surgery since the 1980s.
Why Robotics Came Late to Acute Care Surgery
Interviewer: I always think this next generation of students coming up, right, they've got an advantage because they were born with the remote control in their hand. And so they know what to do. But Dr. Colonna, can you tell me why has robotics traditionally been uncommon in acute care surgery?
Alexander Colonna: Well, the first couple of generations of the robotic platforms that we're all familiar with were kind of clunky, quite frankly, and very expensive. So a lot of places did not have access to that robotic technology. We are innovative, but it takes a lot of evidence to change our practice, and we're not going to jump on a new technology without proven benefit to patients. And I think finally the robotic platform has evolved enough, and the data that we need to make a fundamental change in the tools that we use is finally catching up with the promise of robotics. So I would say that we're cautious adopters in acute care surgery, but now the data and the technology is really pushing us to incorporate this modality for the appropriate emergency general surgery and trauma patients.
The Education Challenge and a Growth Mindset
Interviewer: So, Dr. Krishnamurty, from an education perspective, what challenge does this create for today's residents?
Devi Krishnamurty: Surgical education is challenging in its own way regardless of what generation you are in, because there's always new technology that comes up. Perhaps in the 80s it was laparoscopy. And now we have robotics. But I think the more important part for our trainees that we want them to learn is not just the technical aspect of surgery, but also to have that growth mindset, that new technology will come in when you're practicing, and how do you adapt to it. So I think as our acute care surgeons are learning more and more procedures that can be done robotically, they are demonstrating that growth mindset to our trainees, and that helps them see how you adapt to a new technology in a safe way, using the evidence base, and how do you adapt it to your practice and teach the next generation. And these skills will help them train the future generations of surgeons effectively. So I think it's really cool to be a part of this.
Interviewer: Yeah, you don't get to just sit back. I mean, you have to be a part of the next generation while continuing to bring that next generation up. That's a lot. You don't get to sit back on your heels. You're always looking forward to what's next. When did you first think, we can do this robotically? Or is it something you've always thought we could do robotically and, like you said, we're just waiting for that data to catch up with us?
Adopting Robotics at Utah
Alexander Colonna: Yeah, I was excited 15 years ago when I first saw the first da Vinci Si platform when it came out. The value proposition had to be there for our patients, that we had to be able to deliver the care in an affordable way. And we were able to gain access to the robotic technology at a level that was cost effective for the institution. I started performing robotic surgery about three years ago now, but I had been trying to get my robotic certification for a number of years before that. So also the education from industry and our own protocols on how to certify robotic surgeons had to evolve so that it was actually doable for me with my schedule as an acute care surgeon, because I'm somewhat more time limited than perhaps some of my other partners.
Interviewer: Yeah, I was going to say, I mean, at a large academic institution and being one of a few here in this massive region, we're getting these high-level traumas all the time here. You must be incredibly busy, and to try to fit that in is a lot. Is this something we're training all of our acute care surgeons in?
Alexander Colonna: Yes. Our whole group has embraced acute care robotics, and in acute care surgery the majority of us are trained and certified. We just have two of our partners that still need to finish the training, and they have embarked on it.
Interviewer: Oh, that's exciting. That's really exciting.
Preparing Residents for the Robot
Interviewer: So when you hear these things happening, what is your role, Dr. Krishnamurty, bringing this to the residents?
Devi Krishnamurty: Well, this, as Dr. Colonna mentioned, has been going on for the last 15 years, and there are some services that jumped on the bandwagon a lot sooner than the acute care surgery team. So I have the advantage of having, for example, my team, the colon and rectal surgeons, who have been doing robotics a lot longer. The thoracic surgeons too. So our residents have been exposed to it over the last few years. And Dr. Marshall Baker, who runs our simulation curriculum, has really taken on the challenge of making sure that residents are prepared when they show up and say, Dr. Colonna's operating room, that they have done the modules and the simulation to be prepared to assist or take on, you know, sitting on the console and actually operating safely with supervision. So I think a lot of that work was done by my predecessor, Dr. Lambert, and we continue on that good work. This year we had a robotics challenge for our skills curriculum, and the residents embraced it and really have the top scores on the simulators across the country.
Interviewer: Is this something unique at the University of Utah? Is this something that is progressing across academic centers nationwide? What does this mean for perhaps potential learners that might consider the U?
Alexander Colonna: Well, I think the advent of surgical robotics is going on across the country, so we really are following national trends. I don't think there are any really major academic medical centers in the United States that haven't embraced some facet of robotics. I will say, though, that we are unique at the University of Utah in that we really have amazing residents. Our residents are the cream of the crop from around the country, a very diverse group, very skilled group, and that really pushes us to stay on top of things, because they won't let us slack off or rest or not be at the top of our game. And that also makes them a real pleasure to train. So I'm not surprised at all that they have very competitive scores. You know, I think we all are kind of competitive in surgery anyways.
Interviewer: It's the nature of the group, right?
Devi Krishnamurty: Yeah, that's exactly right.
Interviewer: Really high-performing folks.
What Robotics Makes Possible
Interviewer: Are there procedures that are now possible because of robotics?
Devi Krishnamurty: You know, some of the things in colon and rectal surgery that are really evolving is the ability to do procedures transanally with the single-port platform and, you know, the robotic instruments, with their wristing. We are able to make much smaller incisions or work through body cavities that we wouldn't have thought of doing 15 years ago. So I think it's an exciting time for evolution. I think of it akin to, you know, technology development around cars. You have stick shifts, then automatic transmission, then you have lane assist, and then you have all these things that now lead to self-driving cars. Similarly, there's so many things that we could do with robotics that make surgeries safer in terms of assisted, you know, operating and technology that's in evolution. I'm really excited for this next phase of surgery.
Interviewer: Talk to me about this next phase of surgery. What does it look like?
Alexander Colonna: The sky is really the limit. I think I will be cautious in terms of—all these things are just tools, right? The fundamental principles of human physiology, human anatomy, the pathology that we see don't change that much. You know, a gallbladder is a gallbladder is a gallbladder. It tends to be in the same place in most patients. I think what is evolving is our ability to deliver care for the patient that eases their recovery. So it's less invasive, less traumatic, using single-port surgery, natural orifice surgery, trying to minimize the number of holes that we put in people's bodies that aren't already there. Now, some of the holes that I have to deal with are made by accidents or gunshot wounds or stab wounds, right? But for us in acute care surgery, it's really the robotics platform allowing us to do complicated emergency general surgery procedures without having to make a giant hole in the patient. So, for example, traditionally if someone is stabbed in the left upper quadrant, so on the left side of the body close to the rib cage, we worry about a diaphragmatic injury from that stab wound or gunshot wound. Traditionally we would have to do an open procedure or, you know, futz around with a laparoscopic procedure with not as great visualization to make sure that the diaphragm doesn't have a hole in it that could turn into a large hernia, given enough time. The robotics platform allows us excellent visualization of that particular part of the abdomen, and a much easier time to do an actual repair of a laceration, just because of the visualization and access to that part of the abdomen. So we may have been, in the past, more reticent to do an early operation or make a much larger incision than we needed to. The robotics platform allows us to deliver the right care for the patient in a more minimally invasive fashion than we were in the past. And we are expanding that as we ask, well, what is actually safe to do on the robot? We can do perforated stomach ulcers robotically now. We can do incarcerated inguinal hernias now in a minimally invasive fashion, because the robot is just a powerful tool to get to all the nooks and crannies in the belly.
Interviewer: Yeah. And I understand that bringing robotics to the University of Utah and Huntsman Cancer Institute has been a foundation of these institutions. And so in the past few years, we have brought with, I believe, doctor support, multiple new robotics and specifically the single port, you know, to work in many new, different ways. So that's very exciting.
Advice for Other Programs
Interviewer: If perhaps another residency program would be listening to this conversation, or another emergency medicine program, what is maybe one thing that they could take back to their institution, or take back to their general residency, or look into for their trauma, acute care?
Alexander Colonna: When, you know, we are very, again, for many reasons, we're very lucky here at the University of Utah. And one of our strengths is that we are a very well-resourced university. We have the funding to have all the cool gizmos that a lot of our colleagues in different parts of the country maybe do not have the same access to, the resources that we do. So I would encourage folks at different institutions, different residency programs, to look at what is available and to just keep pushing the care of their particular region of the United States forward. If they have access to new technology or robotics, don't be afraid of it. Critically evaluate it. Look at the data. Look at how you can incorporate these new technologies for the care of your patients in your area.
Devi Krishnamurty: Don't be afraid to try new stuff. Look at it with a critical eye. And we're always here, available at the University of Utah to chat about how we've incorporated new products.
Alexander Colonna: I reached out to my colleagues at the Ohio State University and University of Alabama at Birmingham, Medical University of South Carolina. People have known for years around the country that have embraced this sooner than we have, and I asked them how they did it. What were your obstacles? How did you do this? You know, what did you have to get the OR committee to do? Like, you just try everything with the robot, because the default was just do it open, so we can do that, right? So reach out to your colleagues around the country.
Interviewer: Yeah, that's really good advice. And like you said, you didn't launch this alone. You worked with folks who had done it, who had other resources, who had research. And so, you know, offering to support other teams as they come into that is fantastic, because I know a lot of our teams do that nationally. They do train, they do teach. And, again, medicine is not something that lives in a bubble, right? Regardless of what institution you live at, it's something that's evolving worldwide.
What Residents Experience Here
Interviewer: What might a resident experience here that they might not experience at another program?
Devi Krishnamurty: Well, as Dr. Colonna pointed out, we have good resources. As our interns come in, even before they start, they go to the skills lab and start learning their skills. And robotics is a big part of our skills curriculum and our expectations. So when they come into our program, they should expect to be able to participate, not just in taking care of patients, but also in a curriculum that has been intentionally built for them so they can prepare to be in the operating room, take care of patients, and feel comfortable doing that, rather than that being their first time sitting at the robot console. So I think we have a very dedicated team of educators. We are very blessed in that way, and we send out people that are then able to teach these skills to, you know, wherever they go in the community, to other academic programs. So I think our residents are a really good group of surgeons that then serve our community, mostly here in the Mountain West, but also across the country. And we want to prepare them for all the challenges that they face. And robotics is just one of them.
Interviewer: That's exciting because you're teaching them here, you're sending them off, and then they're taking their skills and then teaching their next generation as well. So really, you know, spider webbing out.
Alexander Colonna: I really can't emphasize that enough, that we have one of the best, if not the best, surgery residencies in the country in terms of the graduates that we produce and the way that we train them here. We are very intentional. I've been here for a couple of years, longer than Dr. Krishnamurty has. Our philosophy here is that we very much want to teach clinically excellent residents. That's the foundation for all the other missions of our academic center: research, teaching, community outreach. All is based on our clinical excellence here, and our residents feel comfortable going into private practice immediately after graduation, and they are very competitive for all the top fellowships. And that is a unique mix that we have worked very strongly to preserve here.
I know Dr. Krishnamurty is going to continue that tradition on as our new program director. We're really good here, and we've worked really hard to match great residents, and we've worked really hard as faculty here to create that environment that is second to none.
Interviewer: And with the limited experience that we on the marketing and communications side, media side, get to work with our residents and fellows, I would have to agree. They're both really smart, but they're also really great humans. Really kind, really, really engaged humans. And that's really been fun to work with on our side as well.
What Do You Hope Will Be True Someday?
Interviewer: So with that discussion on, you know, robotics and bringing robotics into acute care surgery and how do we bring our trainees with us, what do you hope will be true someday because of the work you're doing today?
Alexander Colonna: Well, I hope to train, you know, the future leaders in emergency general surgery and trauma surgery around the country. So not only do I hope our clinical skills and our techniques and our operations get better and better and better, I really hope that we train advocates for public health here. You know, I would very much like my job to not be necessary. And that means, I agree, working on violence prevention, gun control, traffic laws, poverty, crime, I mean, all the social ills that I have to take care of as a trauma and emergency general surgeon. Now, everybody gets appendicitis. But, you know, there are certain vulnerable populations that are more likely to get shot or stabbed. And I would very much like to be out of a job at some point in the future. But I really hope that we're teaching the future leaders of our country that can help, right, with some of these social ills that we've been struggling with for 250-plus years. And, you know, the essence of trauma surgery is prevention.
Interviewer: And, well, we really, really like you and love you here. I would sure love for the same thing. I would love for you to not have to do those things and work on other new things. So I second that, Dr. Krishnamurty.
Devi Krishnamurty: My hope for the future is we will be able to design new solutions to the problems, new procedures that we haven't even imagined yet, that our trainees will be able to take these tools on and develop, you know, innovative procedures that we can do with these new tools so that we can make surgery even safer for patients.
Closing Thoughts
Interviewer: This is exciting in the now and also what's next in the future. Thank you both for joining me today, and I'm looking forward to seeing what's to come.
Alexander Colonna and Devi Krishnamurty: Well, thank you. Thank you very much.
Voices of Surgery Sign-Off
Interviewer: Thank you for joining us for Voices of Surgery. I'm Niki Tonks, your host and producer, and I'm Keslie Ta'afua, your co-producer. Every voice has a story, and we hope you'll join us next time to hear another.
MEET THE FY26 TEAM
-
Faculty
Acute Care Surgery
- Alexander Colonna, MD, MSCIAssociate ProfessorEGS DirectorCo-Director, SICUProgram Director, Surgical Critical Care & Acute Care Surgery Fellowships
- Toby Enniss, MD, MBAProfessorTrauma Medical Director
- Joanna Grudziak, MD, MPHAssistant ProfessorSICU Fellowship Co-DirectorHernia COE Director
- Edward Kimball, MDProfessorDirector, Telehealth Services
- Piroska Kopar, MD, MBAAssociate ProfessorEthics Fellowship Director
- Sarah Lombardo, MD, MScAssistant ProfessorAssociate Director, EGS
- Marta McCrum, MD, MPHAssociate ProfessorDirector of HSR
- Ram Nirula, MD, MPHProfessorDivision ChiefDr. D. Rees and Eleanor T. Jensen Presidential Endowed Chair
- Thomas Shoultz, MDAssociate ProfessorDepartment of Surgery Medical Student AdvisorCo-Director, Phase 2 Surgery Clerkship
- Jason Young, MD, PharmDAssociate ProfessorSICU Section Leader
Gastroesophageal & Bariatric Surgery
- Carla Holcomb, MD, MSPHAssociate Professor
- Anna Ibele, MD, MSCIProfessor
- Ellen Morrow, MD, MSCIAssociate ProfessorAssociate Program Director, Resident Wellness
- Eric Volckmann, MDAssociate ProfessorChief, Section of Gastroesophageal and Bariatric SurgeryDirector of Bariatric SurgeryCo-Director, Comprehensive Weight Management Program
Burn Surgery
- Larissa Epstein, MD, MBAAssistant Professor
- Irma Fleming, MDAssociate ProfessorBurn Associate Medical Director
- Christopher LaChapelle, MD, DPTAssistant Professor
- Giavonni Lewis, MD, MSCIProfessorBurn Section LeaderBurn Medical DirectorProgram Director, Burn Surgery Fellowship
- Callie Thompson, MDAssociate Professor
Community / VA Surgery
- Kevin Bagley, MD, MPHAdjunct Faculty
- Rodney Barker, MDAssistant Professor
- Dinhkim Le, MDAssociate Professor
- Gregory Livers, MDAdjunct Faculty
- William Peche, MD, MSPHAssistant Professor
- Daniel Vargo, MDProfessor
Residents
- Chief ResidentsBecca Empey |Kartemus Heary |Cecilia Im |Fidel Lopez Verdugo | Lauren McGuire |Hannah Wilcox
- Research ResidentsJessica Hall |Dalton Hegeholz | Marisol Monzon | Amir Teimouri-Dereshgi
- PGY 4Abby Alexander | Noah Brown | Annalise Deane | Colleen McDermott | William Starr | Megan Wojick
- PGY 3David Bandbaz | Taylor Beaver | David Brown | Katie Glasgow | Kennedy Jensen | Max Servin-Rojas | Marshall Wallace
- PGY 2Danielle Alaouieh | Cameron Arkin | Peter Beidler | Morgan Blaker | Horacio Carvajal | Mikaela Decoster | Samantha Saperstein
- InternsIndia Burdon Dasbach | Annelise Long | Joseph Maestas | Jacob Slagle | Sydney Vincenti | Evan Watkins
Advanced Practice Clinicians
- Makaela Adamson, PA
- Raymond Allen, NP
- Carl Barney, PA
- Delaney Bennett, PA
- Devon Brower, NP
- Sarah Campbell, NP
- Krystle Ferreira, NP
- Madeline Gallegos, PA
- Emily Gilchrist, NP
- Elisha Haroldsen, PA
- Westley Hunsaker, PA
- Tara Huntsman, APRN
- Stacie Ireland, NP
- Kevin James, NP
- Christopher Koffel, PA
- Jennifer Leseman, PA
- Nicole Miller, NP
- Natalie Miner-Goeckeritz, NP
- Amy Nguyen, PA
- Hillary Price, NP
- Jessica Prymak, PA
- Carine Stearman, NP
- Rebecca Thatcher, PA
- Iliana Thornton, PA
- Crystal Webb, PA
- Marissa Weeks, PA
- Rylee Whitehouse, PA
- Alla Zinger, PA
Staff
- Michelle Adsitt
- Shannon Boseman
- Alexandra Burchette
- Lori Bybee
- Judy Carle
- Molly Collings
- Daniel Harkness
- Sean Hepner
- Jordan Johnson
- James Kalvelage
- Andrea Marsing
- Lindy Millet
- Stephanie Ostendorf
- Ermina Selimovic
- Deborah Shaw
- Amy Thomson
- Saranda Trujillo